How Do You Handle Broody Hens?

Free Ranging and Training Chickens...

“I’ve got a few hens that have gone broody, and I’m not sure how to handle them. Should I let them sit on eggs, or try to break the broodiness? What’s the best approach?” Thanks, Ashley, from Brisbane, Australia.

How to Handle Broody Hens: A Comprehensive Guide

Dealing with broody hens can be both a challenge and an opportunity, Ashley. Let’s explore the ins and outs of handling these determined mother hens and help you make the best decision for your flock in Brisbane.

Understanding Broodiness in Hens

Broodiness is a natural behavior in hens, triggered by hormonal changes, usually during spring and summer. When a hen goes broody, she’ll stop laying eggs and dedicate herself to sitting on a clutch of eggs, waiting for them to hatch. This instinct is strong in some breeds, like Silkies and Orpingtons, while less common in others, such as Leghorns.

Signs of a Broody Hen

To effectively manage broody hens, Ashley, you need to recognize the signs. Here are some telltale indicators:

  • Staying in the nesting box for extended periods
  • Puffing up feathers and making a distinctive clucking sound
  • Pecking or hissing when approached
  • Plucking out her own breast feathers to create a bare patch for better egg contact
  • Reduced appetite and less time spent foraging

To Break or Not to Break: That is the Question

When faced with a broody hen, you have two main options: allow her to hatch eggs or attempt to break the broodiness. Each approach has its pros and cons, and the best choice depends on your specific situation and goals.

Allowing the Hen to Hatch Eggs

If you decide to let nature take its course, here’s what you need to know:

Pros of Letting a Hen Hatch Eggs:

  • Natural process that can be rewarding to observe
  • Opportunity to expand your flock
  • Hen-raised chicks often grow up to be hardier and more self-sufficient

Cons of Letting a Hen Hatch Eggs:

  • Reduced egg production from the broody hen
  • Potential for unsuccessful hatches, leading to wasted time and resources
  • Need for additional space and care for chicks

Steps to Support a Broody Hen:

  1. Provide a quiet, secluded nesting area
  2. Ensure access to food and water nearby
  3. Mark eggs with a pencil to track laying dates
  4. Remove any cracked or dirty eggs
  5. Limit disturbances during the 21-day incubation period

Ashley, if you decide to let your hen hatch eggs, remember that not all eggs may be fertile. If you don’t have a rooster, you’ll need to source fertilized eggs for your broody hen.

Breaking the Broodiness

If hatching chicks doesn’t align with your plans, you may want to break the broody behavior. Here’s what you need to know about this approach:

Pros of Breaking Broodiness:

  • Maintains egg production
  • Prevents potential health issues associated with prolonged brooding
  • Allows for better flock management

Cons of Breaking Broodiness:

  • Can be time-consuming and potentially stressful for the hen
  • May need to be repeated if the hen becomes broody again
  • Goes against the hen’s natural instincts

Methods to Break Broodiness:

1. The “Broody Breaker” Cage Method:

This involves moving the hen to a wire-bottom cage with good airflow. The cooler environment and inability to nest can help reset her hormones.

  • Place the hen in the cage with food and water
  • Ensure the cage is in a well-lit area
  • Keep her there for 3-5 days, or until she stops exhibiting broody behavior

2. The “Cold Water Bath” Method:

This method involves gently placing the hen’s underside in cool (not cold) water for a few minutes. The temperature change can help break the broody cycle.

  • Fill a bucket or sink with cool water
  • Gently lower the hen’s underside into the water for 30 seconds to a minute
  • Repeat once or twice daily for a few days

3. The “Isolation” Method:

Similar to the broody breaker cage, this involves moving the hen to a separate area away from nesting boxes and other hens.

  • Place the hen in a separate coop or run
  • Ensure she has no access to nesting materials
  • Keep her isolated for 3-5 days

Remember, Ashley, consistency is key when trying to break broodiness. It may take several attempts before you see results.

Preventing Broodiness

While you can’t completely prevent broodiness, there are steps you can take to minimize its occurrence:

  • Collect eggs frequently throughout the day
  • Avoid using fake eggs in nesting boxes
  • Ensure proper lighting in the coop (14-16 hours of light per day)
  • Maintain a comfortable coop temperature
  • Consider breeds less prone to broodiness if it’s a recurring issue

Health Considerations for Broody Hens

Broodiness can impact a hen’s health if not managed properly. Here are some health concerns to watch for:

  • Dehydration and malnutrition: Broody hens often neglect eating and drinking. Ensure easy access to fresh water and nutritious food.
  • Mites and lice: Extended periods in the nesting box can lead to parasite infestations. Regular health checks are crucial.
  • Egg binding: If a hen becomes broody while still having eggs in her system, it can lead to egg binding. This is a serious condition requiring immediate veterinary attention.
  • Stress: Both allowing broodiness and attempting to break it can be stressful for hens. Monitor for signs of excessive stress.

The Impact of Climate on Broody Hens

Ashley, given that you’re in Brisbane, it’s worth considering how the local climate might affect your broody hens. Brisbane’s subtropical climate, with its hot summers and mild winters, can influence broody behavior:

  • Hot weather can make broodiness more challenging for hens, increasing the risk of dehydration and heat stress.
  • Ensure proper ventilation in the coop, especially during summer months.
  • Consider providing cooling options like misters or shallow water baths for your hens during extreme heat.
  • The mild winters in Brisbane might mean you see broody behavior outside of the typical spring/summer season.

Broody Hens and Flock Dynamics

A broody hen can affect the entire flock dynamics:

  • Other hens may be discouraged from using the nesting box occupied by a broody hen.
  • Broody hens may become more aggressive, altering the pecking order.
  • If multiple hens go broody simultaneously, it can significantly impact egg production.

Monitor your flock closely when dealing with broody hens to ensure harmony and productivity.

Legal Considerations

Before deciding to let your broody hen hatch chicks, Ashley, it’s worth checking local regulations in Brisbane regarding backyard poultry. Some areas may have restrictions on:

  • The number of chickens you can keep
  • Roosters (which you’d need for fertilized eggs)
  • Noise levels (especially relevant if you end up with roosters)

Ensuring you’re compliant with local laws will prevent any issues down the line.

Final Thoughts…

Handling broody hens, Ashley, is all about balance. Whether you choose to let nature take its course or intervene to break the broodiness, the key is to prioritize the health and well-being of your hens. Remember, each hen is unique, and what works for one might not work for another. Don’t be afraid to adjust your approach as needed.

Your dedication to understanding and caring for your flock is commendable. Brisbane’s climate presents its own set of challenges, but with the right knowledge and preparation, you’re well-equipped to handle whatever your broody hens throw your way. Thank you for reaching out with this question – it’s clear you’re committed to being a responsible and caring chicken keeper. Keep up the great work, and enjoy the rewarding journey of backyard chicken raising!


Whether you're a complete beginner and don't know where to start, or you're a seasoned chicken keeping professional and just want practical "how to" advice on tap our guide to keeping chickens has got you covered...

Chicken Keeping Book

Leave a reply

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}