How Do You Manage Multiple Broody Hens?

Free Ranging and Training Chickens...

“I’m having trouble managing multiple broody hens in my backyard coop. Any advice on how to handle this situation without stressing out the birds or disrupting egg production?” Thanks a bunch, Sarah, Melbourne, Australia.

Managing Multiple Broody Hens: A Comprehensive Guide

Hey Sarah! It’s great to hear from a fellow chicken keeper all the way from Melbourne. Managing multiple broody hens can indeed be a challenge, but don’t worry – I’ve got some tried-and-true strategies to help you navigate this situation without causing undue stress to your feathered friends or compromising egg production.

Understanding Broodiness in Hens

Before we dive into management techniques, it’s essential to understand what causes broodiness and why it can be problematic when multiple hens go broody simultaneously.

Broodiness is a natural instinct in hens, triggered by hormonal changes, usually in response to longer daylight hours and the presence of eggs in the nest. When a hen goes broody, she’ll sit on a clutch of eggs, only leaving the nest for brief periods to eat, drink, and relieve herself. This behavior can last for several weeks, during which the hen won’t lay any new eggs.

While broodiness is great for hatching chicks, it can be problematic in a backyard setting, especially when multiple hens go broody at once. This can lead to reduced egg production, aggressive behavior, and potential health issues for the broody hens.

Identifying Broody Hens

Sarah, to effectively manage broody hens, you first need to be able to identify them. Here are some tell-tale signs:

  • Staying on the nest for extended periods
  • Flattening their bodies and fluffing out their feathers when approached
  • Making a distinctive clucking sound
  • Becoming aggressive or protective of their nest
  • Plucking out their breast feathers to create better skin-to-egg contact

Strategies for Managing Multiple Broody Hens

Now that we’ve covered the basics, let’s explore some effective strategies for managing multiple broody hens in your Melbourne backyard:

1. Break the Broody Cycle

One of the most common methods to manage broody hens is to break the broody cycle. This involves removing the hen from her nest and placing her in a separate area, often called a “broody breaker” or “sin bin.” This area should have:

  • Wire flooring to allow cool air to circulate under the hen
  • Plenty of food and water
  • No nesting material

Keep the hen in this area for 3-4 days, after which she should return to normal behavior. If she remains broody, repeat the process.

2. Use a Broody Coop

If you have the space, Sarah, consider setting up a separate broody coop. This allows you to manage your broody hens without disrupting the rest of your flock. In the broody coop, you can either:

  • Allow the broody hens to hatch and raise chicks if that’s your goal
  • Use the space as a larger version of a broody breaker to manage multiple hens at once

3. Collect Eggs Frequently

To discourage broodiness, collect eggs several times a day. This reduces the chances of a hen becoming attached to a clutch of eggs and going broody. It’s a simple but effective preventative measure.

4. Block Access to Favorite Nesting Spots

If you notice certain nesting boxes are more popular and tend to encourage broodiness, try blocking access to these spots temporarily. This can help break the cycle and encourage hens to use other nesting areas.

5. Use Fake Eggs

Replace real eggs with fake ones made of wood or plastic. When a hen realizes the eggs aren’t hatching, she may abandon her broody behavior. This method can be particularly effective when dealing with multiple broody hens.

6. Provide Distractions

Offer your hens plenty of distractions to keep them busy and less likely to go broody. This can include:

  • Hanging vegetables or treats for them to peck at
  • Providing dust bathing areas
  • Offering foraging toys or scattered treats

7. Consider Breeds

Some chicken breeds are more prone to broodiness than others. If you’re finding it challenging to manage multiple broody hens, you might want to consider introducing less broody breeds to your flock in the future, Sarah.

Caring for Broody Hens

While managing broody hens, it’s crucial to ensure their health and well-being:

  • Ensure they have access to food and water, even if they’re reluctant to leave the nest
  • Check for signs of illness or parasites, as broody hens can be more susceptible
  • Monitor their weight, as some hens may lose condition while broody
  • Ensure proper ventilation to prevent overheating

When to Let Nature Take Its Course

Sometimes, Sarah, it might be beneficial to allow a hen to complete her broody cycle, especially if:

  • You want to hatch chicks naturally
  • The hen is particularly persistent and other methods haven’t worked
  • You have the space and resources to manage a broody hen and potential chicks

If you decide to let a hen hatch chicks, ensure she has a safe, quiet space away from the rest of the flock. Provide her with a clutch of fertile eggs (if you want chicks) or fake eggs (if you don’t).

Managing Egg Production

When dealing with multiple broody hens, egg production can take a hit. Here are some strategies to maintain egg production:

  • Quickly identify and manage broody hens to minimize disruption
  • Ensure the rest of your flock has optimal nutrition to support egg laying
  • Maintain a consistent light schedule (about 14-16 hours of light per day) to encourage laying
  • Consider introducing new layers to your flock if egg production is a priority

Preventing Broodiness

While it’s not always possible to prevent broodiness entirely, there are steps you can take to reduce its occurrence:

  • Maintain a consistent routine for your flock
  • Keep the coop cool and well-ventilated
  • Remove any eggs laid outside of nesting boxes promptly
  • Discourage hens from sleeping in nesting boxes

Final Thoughts…

Sarah, managing multiple broody hens can be a bit of a juggling act, but with patience and the right strategies, it’s entirely doable. Remember, the key is to act quickly when you spot signs of broodiness, use a combination of methods to break the broody cycle, and always prioritize the health and well-being of your hens.

Every flock is unique, so don’t be afraid to experiment with different techniques to find what works best for your chickens in Melbourne. With time, you’ll become an expert at managing broody hens, ensuring a happy, healthy flock and a steady supply of eggs.

Thanks for reaching out with your question, Sarah. Your dedication to your chickens is admirable, and I’m confident you’ll master the art of managing broody hens in no time. Keep up the great work, and don’t hesitate to ask if you need any more poultry-related advice!


Whether you're a complete beginner and don't know where to start, or you're a seasoned chicken keeping professional and just want practical "how to" advice on tap our guide to keeping chickens has got you covered...

Chicken Keeping Book

Leave a reply

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}